State public safety chief slams judge for dismissing DUI charge against Tupelo city attorney

The state chief of public safety strongly criticized Lee County Justice Court Judge Chuck Hopkins for his reasoning in dismissing a drunk driving charge against Tupelo city attorney Ben Logan.

Posted: Jul 23, 2019 9:22 AM
Updated: Jul 23, 2019 6:56 PM

Editor's Note: A statement from Lee County Justice Court Judge Chuck Hopkins has been added to this article.

JACKSON, Miss. (WTVA) -- The state chief of public safety strongly criticized Lee County Justice Court Judge Chuck Hopkins for his reasoning in dismissing a drunk driving charge against Tupelo city attorney Ben Logan.

"This case is nothing more than local politics getting the end result they wanted by blaming a state agency," wrote Mississippi Department of Public Safety Commissioner Marshall Fisher in a statement released Monday.

On July 11, Hopkins ruled the MHP roadblock in Tupelo where Logan was pulled over was unconstitutional because troopers did not have approval from a supervisor.

RELATED: Judge dismisses DUI refusal case against Tupelo city attorney

The commissioner responded there was nothing unconstitutional about the roadblock and troopers did have supervisor approval from a highway patrol master sergeant even though there is no Mississippi Supreme Court ruling requiring such approval.

"Judges are to use the law and facts when deciding whether police actions are constitutional, and Justice Court Judge Chuck Hopkins had neither the law nor the facts on his side when he dismissed the case," said Fisher.

In his statement, the commissioner cited four instances where the Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law the night in December 2018 when Logan was arrested:

"The Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law when they noticed a vehicle attempt to avoid a safety checkpoint by unexplainably pulling into a private drive of a closed business after 10:00 p.m. That vehicle was driven by Ben Logan."

"The Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law when a corporal, staff sergeant and master sergeant were present conducting the safety checkpoint."

"The Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law when its officers observed a driver with red, glassy eyes and slurred speech blow into a portable breath test – after refusing the first time and responding with 'Just lock me up.' That driver was Ben Logan."

"The Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law while the non-attorney Justice Court judge ignored it and then created his own requirements for a safety checkpoint."

Hopkins told the Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal he dismissed the charge against Logan because no law enforcement supervisor authorized the checkpoint.

But Fisher said a supervisor did give authorization -- a highway patrol master sergeant.

In the final clause of the statement, Fisher said, "The Mississippi Highway Patrol remains committed to making the highways safe for all residents of Mississippi, including, but certainly not limited to, city attorneys and justice court judges."

"We're going to handle our business in court, and do that by following the law," Hopkins said in a statement to WTVA. 

Below is the entire statement issued Monday by Mississippi Public Safety Commissioner Marshall Fisher:

Judges are to use the law and facts when deciding whether police actions are
constitutional, and Justice Court Judge Chuck Hopkins had neither the law nor the facts
on his side when he dismissed the case against Tupelo City Attorney Ben Logan.

The Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law when they noticed a vehicle attempt to
avoid a safety checkpoint by unexplainably pulling into a private drive of a closed business
after 10:00 p.m. That vehicle was driven by Ben Logan.

The Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law when a Corporal, Staff Sergeant, and
Master Sergeant were present conducting the safety checkpoint.

The Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law when its officers observed a driver with
red, glassy eyes and slurred speech blow into a portable breath test – after refusing the
first time and responding with “Just lock me up.” That driver was Ben Logan.

The Mississippi Highway Patrol followed the law while the non-attorney Justice Court
judge ignored it and then created his own requirements for a safety checkpoint.

Judge Hopkins was quoted as saying, “There has to be something from higher above
saying it’s OK.” This is incorrect. No Mississippi Supreme Court case requires law
enforcement have permission from their superior before conducting a safety checkpoint.
But even if that permission was required, the troopers in this case had it. The Master
Sergeant was present and even witnessed Ben Logan avoid the safety checkpoint. Judge
Hopkins would know this had he followed the law and conducted a hearing where
evidence could be presented by the parties. Instead, Judge Hopkins relied on briefs
submitted by the attorneys instead of relying on sworn testimony from any of the available
witnesses.

This case is nothing more than local politics getting the end result they wanted by blaming
a state agency. When non-lawyer judges start making decisions on what is considered
constitutional under the law, these types of mistakes will continue to happen. And when
judges make public statements in an attempt to justify their rulings, the Mississippi
Highway Patrol will continue to defend itself.

The Mississippi Highway Patrol remains committed to making the highways safe for all
residents of Mississippi, including, but certainly not limited to, city attorneys and
justice court judges.

Marshall Fisher
Commissioner

MORE: Open this link to see the statement.

Mississippi Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 112123

Reported Deaths: 3223
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hinds7796173
DeSoto670178
Harrison484483
Jackson435081
Rankin383786
Madison373993
Lee344979
Forrest296377
Jones283782
Washington252197
Lafayette242642
Lauderdale2376131
Lamar217138
Bolivar198377
Oktibbeha195854
Neshoba1814111
Lowndes174962
Panola166337
Leflore160787
Sunflower157649
Warren152755
Monroe145972
Pontotoc143819
Pike137256
Lincoln135555
Copiah135036
Marshall134826
Scott123829
Coahoma123436
Grenada120038
Yazoo119333
Simpson118649
Union115225
Holmes113560
Leake113340
Tate113239
Itawamba110424
Pearl River108958
Adams104343
Prentiss102619
Wayne98721
Alcorn96012
George93917
Marion92942
Covington92525
Tippah85921
Newton84427
Chickasaw82625
Winston82221
Tallahatchie81825
Tishomingo79341
Hancock78127
Attala77626
Clarke72349
Clay67621
Jasper67417
Walthall63327
Calhoun61412
Noxubee59617
Smith58316
Claiborne53216
Montgomery52923
Tunica52217
Lawrence49914
Yalobusha49314
Perry48122
Carroll46312
Greene45518
Stone45014
Amite41713
Quitman4146
Humphreys41216
Jefferson Davis39811
Webster36613
Wilkinson33020
Kemper32015
Benton3154
Sharkey27814
Jefferson27010
Franklin2373
Choctaw2036
Issaquena1063
Unassigned00

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 153016

Reported Deaths: 2633
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson22563372
Mobile14335314
Tuscaloosa10023133
Montgomery9759196
Madison904893
Shelby709960
Lee644966
Baldwin640569
Marshall428248
Calhoun412759
Etowah405749
Morgan396833
Houston364632
DeKalb319628
Elmore310752
St. Clair282142
Limestone270828
Walker268892
Talladega258435
Cullman227623
Lauderdale208740
Autauga201029
Jackson200915
Franklin199731
Colbert192228
Russell19053
Dallas185627
Blount184824
Chilton181731
Escambia171328
Coffee16669
Covington166029
Dale163451
Pike130512
Chambers130143
Tallapoosa128686
Clarke127117
Marion104729
Butler99840
Barbour9889
Marengo97221
Winston90413
Geneva8417
Pickens80517
Lawrence80031
Randolph79814
Bibb79114
Hale74529
Cherokee72214
Clay71912
Lowndes70127
Henry6376
Bullock63517
Monroe6319
Washington62212
Crenshaw59330
Perry5806
Wilcox55912
Conecuh55713
Fayette55312
Cleburne5287
Macon52820
Sumter46721
Lamar4565
Choctaw38712
Greene33916
Coosa1973
Out of AL00
Unassigned00
Tupelo
Clear
65° wxIcon
Hi: 86° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 65°
Columbus
Overcast
68° wxIcon
Hi: 86° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 68°
Oxford
Clear
64° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 64°
Feels Like: 64°
Starkville
Clear
63° wxIcon
Hi: 84° Lo: 64°
Feels Like: 63°
WTVA Radar
WTVA Temperatures
WTVA Severe Weather