How Maxine Waters stood up to Steven Mnuchin

Article Image

Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin and Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA) argued over a scheduling conflict during a House Committee on Financial Services hearing.

Posted: Apr 11, 2019 11:00 AM
Updated: Apr 11, 2019 11:00 AM

Tuesday's showdown between Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and House Financial Services Committee Chair Maxine Waters offered a handy lesson in classic "mansplaining."

For anyone not versed in the term -- though few women have been fortunate enough to not experience it themselves -- mansplaining is when a man tries to explain something to a woman, the "slower species," in a condescending or patronizing way.

But it's one thing for a woman to experience it in a meeting at work or at a party with some boorish guy spelling things out. It's quite another to have it demonstrated so ably on national television by an official in an administration that is rapidly shedding women in high positions, and to see it satisfyingly slapped down by a woman -- another highly-placed government official, in this case.

In this, Maxine Waters did women (and men), young and old, a favor by publicly identifying what was happening -- and modeling how to respond.

Here's how it went down: Mnuchin was appearing before the committee to discuss his plans for responding to Democrats' requests for President Donald Trump's tax returns. Mnuchin wanted to leave at 5:15 to get to another meeting on his schedule. Waters would not relent; she urged him to stay until 5:30, so that the full committee could question him.

After a tense exchange, with Mnuchin checking his watch, appearing to be gathering his papers to leave, he said, "If you'd wish to keep me here so I don't have my important meeting, and continue to grill me, then we can do that. I will cancel my meeting and I will not be back here."

She took him up on it; he appeared stunned. "You made me an offer. I accepted," said Waters. "I did not make you an offer; let's be clear," Mnuchin huffed. "You're instructing me, you're ordering me to stay here." She told him he was free to leave when he wanted.

Instead of appealing to her in a reasonable, mature, respectful way, however, he chose the sarcastic, arrogant, belittling route of a bully -- and a mansplainer -- offering her detailed instructions on how to end the meeting, as if she were a child and did not understand the problem here.

"Please dismiss everybody," Mnuchin told Waters, his impatience and irritation evident. And then, raising his arm and miming banging a gavel, "I believe you are supposed to take the gravel [sic] and bang it." (Please note that in treating Waters as if she were too unintelligent to know how to end her own hearing, or even to operate a gavel, he misnamed the instrument she would use to end it, calling it a "gravel.")

Although a new-ish term, described in 2008 by author Rebecca Solnit in a piece entitled "Men Explain Things to Me; Facts Didn't Get in Their Way," mansplaining is certainly not a new phenomenon. Men have been explaining things to women for years. As more and more women come to positions of power equal to those of men, however, it's being called out more and more.

Perhaps as cover for this infantilizing of women, men sometimes portray it as the kind of all-in-good-fun "ball-busting" they engage each other with. In this reading, women are supposed to stop being so sensitive and just take it, just like the guys would. That's of course nonsense.

And it wasn't the case here. The response to Mnuchin's arrogance -- his public pillorying when the video started to get around online -- was fully warranted.

He was rude and entitled. As many have pointed out on social media, it's unlikely that he would have responded in such a way if Waters were a white man, or any man. Meanwhile, it's likely that if roles had been reversed -- had Waters or any female politician interacted with a man in such a manner, whether or not he was in charge, she'd have been hung out to dry.

It's possible that Mnuchin, who has become known for his arrogance, would have responded the same way to a male colleague refusing to give him his way -- particularly a Democrat asking tough questions about his boss. (Waters' response to his gavel instructions, by the way: "Please do not instruct me as to how I am to conduct this committee.")

Politicians come to verbal blows all the time, our current commander in chief having set the tone for a heightened state of anti-etiquette. (As one recent piece put it, "we live in an age of rude politicians.") Either way, Tuesday's head-to-head conflict hopefully offers some proof to our current leaders that bully tactics exposed to the light of day generally backfire -- and that mansplaining doesn't work.

Mississippi Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 113876

Reported Deaths: 3238
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hinds7894177
DeSoto693279
Harrison512983
Jackson450384
Rankin389486
Madison381293
Lee351479
Forrest300778
Jones289184
Washington256499
Lafayette248343
Lauderdale2437134
Lamar224238
Oktibbeha200854
Bolivar200477
Neshoba1842111
Lowndes178362
Panola169139
Leflore165887
Sunflower160949
Warren154355
Monroe148172
Pontotoc146119
Marshall141229
Lincoln138957
Pike138256
Copiah136936
Coahoma124936
Scott124929
Yazoo121733
Grenada121638
Simpson121249
Union117425
Tate116039
Leake114640
Holmes114460
Pearl River112959
Itawamba112225
Adams107343
Prentiss104819
Wayne100821
Alcorn98712
George97918
Covington97026
Marion94642
Tippah88922
Newton85627
Chickasaw84026
Tallahatchie84025
Winston83321
Hancock81628
Tishomingo80041
Attala79026
Clarke74351
Clay68421
Jasper67917
Walthall63827
Calhoun62212
Noxubee59617
Smith59116
Montgomery54323
Claiborne53716
Tunica52917
Yalobusha52614
Lawrence51214
Perry48723
Carroll48012
Greene47318
Stone46414
Humphreys42816
Amite42113
Quitman4196
Jefferson Davis40511
Webster37013
Wilkinson33720
Benton3335
Kemper32215
Sharkey28314
Jefferson27510
Franklin2403
Choctaw2056
Issaquena1074
Unassigned00

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 155915

Reported Deaths: 2674
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson22988375
Mobile16788315
Tuscaloosa10235140
Montgomery9978197
Madison922894
Shelby727463
Baldwin661569
Lee651765
Marshall437249
Calhoun422461
Etowah421450
Morgan407135
Houston371734
DeKalb336029
Elmore317353
St. Clair289142
Limestone279730
Walker275593
Talladega263635
Cullman239925
Lauderdale218042
Jackson212515
Franklin203231
Autauga203030
Colbert198731
Russell19283
Blount191125
Dallas186327
Chilton185832
Coffee173211
Escambia172230
Covington171429
Dale166551
Chambers134343
Clarke133617
Pike132713
Tallapoosa131387
Marion107129
Barbour10129
Butler100240
Marengo100222
Winston91913
Geneva8617
Lawrence83732
Pickens83618
Bibb82514
Randolph82016
Hale75830
Clay73612
Washington73412
Cherokee73114
Lowndes70428
Monroe64510
Henry6436
Bullock63917
Crenshaw60330
Perry5856
Fayette56913
Wilcox56412
Conecuh56013
Cleburne5518
Macon53020
Lamar4745
Sumter47221
Choctaw39012
Greene34216
Coosa2033
Out of AL00
Unassigned00
Tupelo
Overcast
54° wxIcon
Hi: 58° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 54°
Columbus
Overcast
55° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 55°
Oxford
Overcast
50° wxIcon
Hi: 54° Lo: 47°
Feels Like: 50°
Starkville
Overcast
52° wxIcon
Hi: 58° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 52°
WTVA Radar
WTVA Temperatures
WTVA Severe Weather