Judge dismisses one count in Harvey Weinstein's criminal case

A New York judge dismissed count six of Harvey Weinstein's criminal indictment Thursday, which was a crimina...

Posted: Oct 12, 2018 9:39 AM
Updated: Oct 12, 2018 9:39 AM

A New York judge dismissed count six of Harvey Weinstein's criminal indictment Thursday, which was a criminal sexual act in the first degree.

The count stems from charges brought forth against the disgraced movie producer in May and July by the Manhattan District Attorney's Office.

Business figures

Harvey Weinstein

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Criminal law

Law and legal system

Crimes against persons

Criminal offenses

Sex crimes

Sexual assault

Sexual misconduct

Society

A source familiar with the investigation told CNN at the time that the criminal sex act charge was from a case involving aspiring actress Lucia Evans, who alleged Weinstein forced her to perform oral sex on him in his Tribeca office in 2004. She first spoke out about the alleged incident to Ronan Farrow in the New Yorker last fall.

The reason that count was dropped today was due, in part, to a newly unsealed letter that prosecutor Joan Illuzzi-Orbon sent to defense counsel Benjamin Brafman in September.

It cites alleged inconsistencies in Evans' story.

Although the letter does not specifically name Evans, Brafman named her in court, and her attorney, Carrie Goldberg, spoke to reporters after the hearing ended. Goldberg said that the decision "does not invalidate the truth of her (client's) claims."

According to the letter, when Evans first met Weinstein at a restaurant in the summer of 2004, she says she was accompanied by a friend. That friend was interviewed by detective Nicholas DiGaudio in February of 2018.

The friend allegedly said during that interview that Evans told her she had engaged in consensual contact with Weinstein: oral sex in exchange for a job.

The friend also told the detective she was contacted by The New Yorker and only told them "something inappropriate happened."

According to the letter, Detective DiGaudio responded to the friend's claims by saying that, going forward, "less is more," and that the witness had no obligation to cooperate. He never went back to the DA with this information.

Evans' friend subsequently contacted the district attorney's office in August of 2018, after Weinstein was indicted, to reiterate that Evans had told her she willingly engaged with Weinstein.

Evans was again interviewed by the district attorney's office in August 2018. She stated she "never consented to any form of sex with the defendant," contradicting her friend's account.

The District Attorney's office additionally states in the letter that they interviewed Detective DiGaudio concerning the inconsistencies. He acknowledged speaking by phone with the friend and her attorney, along with failing to inform the DA's office of the important details of that discussion. DiGaudio also denied telling the friend she did not have to come forward and that "less is more."

The DA says they obtained a draft email from Evans to her now-husband recounting the incident with Weinstein. According to the letter, that account differs from what she told the DA. Evans says the inconsistencies come from her flawed memory, and that she never disclosed the details of the sexual assault to her husband.

Goldberg said the prosecution "jumped ship" and "ultimately she was caught between the middle of a feud between the NYPD and the DA's office."

Related: Harvey Weinstein is charged with rape and sex abuse in cases involving 2 women

Goldberg added that despite District Attorney Cy Vance not opposing the motion to dismiss the charge against Weinstein, her client's claims remain and this "does speak to a system desperate in need of reform."

"People always ask why don't sexual assault survivors come forward, this is why. Today is why," Goldberg said. Goldberg detailed how prosecutors used Evans for months and "put her through needless torture."

The attorney said her client will continue her fight in other venues.

"Victims are becoming warriors and this is just the beginning," she added.

Weinstein had previously pleaded not guilty to the six sex crimes he's been charged with in New York, including two counts of rape. The charges are based on claims from three accusers.

Benjamin Brafman, Weinstein's attorney, has filed a motion to dismiss the case and told reporters Thursday that he intends to refile that motion for the five remaining charges.

"What troubles me is that when you are vilified in the media, as has Mr. Weinstein, there is a rush to judgment, which is offensive to the concept of fairness and due process," Brafman said. "There is a rush to arrest, there is pressure to arrest, and what we see is that happened in this case."

Prosecutor Joan Illuzzi-Orbon told reporters she remains confident in the case against Weinstein.

"Nothing in this disclosure of count six impacts the strength of the case," Illuzzi-Orbontold said. "We are moving full steam ahead."

The next hearing in the case is scheduled for December 20.

Mississippi Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 268672

Reported Deaths: 5917
CountyCasesDeaths
DeSoto17928195
Hinds17030337
Harrison14510212
Rankin11315223
Jackson11054193
Lee9109147
Madison8663171
Jones6853120
Forrest6260125
Lauderdale6161196
Lowndes5582123
Lafayette5269101
Lamar508765
Washington4965125
Bolivar4164110
Oktibbeha411585
Panola389881
Pontotoc380460
Monroe3727111
Warren3716103
Marshall360172
Union360165
Pearl River3527106
Neshoba3516158
Leflore3132110
Lincoln308389
Hancock300963
Sunflower294277
Tate281862
Alcorn274055
Pike272984
Itawamba271263
Scott264055
Yazoo258456
Prentiss255454
Coahoma252455
Copiah251549
Tippah251551
Simpson244872
Leake238967
Marion228274
Covington224873
Grenada224673
Wayne216336
Adams216271
Winston208271
George206440
Newton201447
Attala197465
Tishomingo196361
Chickasaw190245
Jasper183138
Holmes172568
Clay168637
Tallahatchie158035
Stone153625
Clarke148762
Calhoun142022
Smith131926
Yalobusha124935
Walthall115438
Greene114929
Noxubee114526
Montgomery112936
Lawrence107917
Carroll106922
Perry105931
Amite102727
Webster98024
Claiborne90125
Tunica89621
Jefferson Davis89330
Benton86923
Humphreys85625
Kemper81220
Quitman7169
Franklin71017
Choctaw64013
Wilkinson60125
Jefferson57321
Sharkey45717
Issaquena1616
Unassigned00

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 445909

Reported Deaths: 6896
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson651891049
Mobile32138590
Madison28596223
Tuscaloosa21703276
Montgomery20220336
Shelby19584138
Baldwin17496216
Lee13378109
Morgan12741145
Etowah12196189
Calhoun11626228
Marshall10513126
Houston9097168
Limestone842481
Cullman8363125
Elmore8283112
Lauderdale7986112
DeKalb7935112
St. Clair7915139
Talladega6552112
Walker6068184
Jackson605649
Colbert560194
Blount551794
Autauga544065
Coffee470569
Dale415186
Franklin378150
Russell362816
Chilton348079
Covington344681
Escambia342244
Tallapoosa3184109
Dallas314197
Chambers308575
Clarke307339
Pike267735
Lawrence256958
Marion255763
Winston235243
Bibb224751
Geneva214747
Marengo212031
Pickens201831
Barbour188240
Hale187444
Fayette181230
Butler175960
Cherokee167433
Henry161325
Monroe153521
Randolph148236
Washington144027
Clay131050
Crenshaw126245
Macon124337
Cleburne123627
Lamar121324
Lowndes117636
Wilcox109422
Bullock105829
Perry100518
Conecuh98222
Sumter90828
Greene78323
Coosa64619
Choctaw52224
Out of AL00
Unassigned00
Tupelo
Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 51° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 30°
Columbus
Cloudy
45° wxIcon
Hi: 56° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 38°
Oxford
Cloudy
36° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 36°
Feels Like: 29°
Starkville
Cloudy
43° wxIcon
Hi: 55° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 37°
WTVA Radar
WTVA Temperatures
WTVA Severe Weather