Trump Org. CFO granted immunity in Cohen case

A top figure in President Donald Trump's orbit has been granted immunity in the investigation into hush money payments made to two women who alleged they had affairs with Trump, a source familiar with the matter told CNN.

Posted: Aug 25, 2018 8:26 PM
Updated: Aug 25, 2018 8:38 PM

We've become accustomed to President Trump criticizing Special Counsel Robert Mueller's investigation, his own Justice Department and even Jeff Sessions, the man he personally selected to be his attorney general (over and over again).

On Fox News Thursday, he took it a step further. While continuing to vilify Michael Cohen, his former trusted lawyer and personal fixer, Trump took aim at one of the pillars of federal criminal prosecutions -- the cooperating witness.

Trump said that cooperation deals are not fair and "almost should be outlawed." "Flipping," Trump said, "almost ought to be illegal."

It is easy to see why the President would make such a "proposal." To be sure, cooperating has its ugly side. And while the plea agreement that Cohen reached with prosecutors this week apparently did not require that he cooperate with federal authorities, Trump is no doubt worried about who may yet.

Just Friday, CNN reported that the chief financial officer for the Trump Organization, Allen Weisselberg, was granted immunity to provide information about the hush money payoffs made by Cohen on Trump's behalf.

As a practicing defense lawyer in federal court, I'm very happy that the President made these "flipping" comments. I intend to quote him liberally in my next trial and I will suggest at every opportunity that cooperating witnesses cannot be believed, and that flipping itself should be outlawed.

But that argument ignores the fact that cooperating witnesses are the fuel in the tank that keeps the federal criminal justice system running. Without "flipping," federal prosecutors would have a very hard time doing their job.

The fact is that cooperation is such a vital part of the federal criminal justice system that judges routinely instruct jurors who may be skeptical of the process that it is perfectly "lawful and proper," although they may want to be a little more skeptical of the testimony of a witness who has a deal with the government.

Why? Let's step back and consider how the cooperation deal process works:

I've been defending people charged in federal criminal cases for almost 25 years. In my experience, it is rare for a federal prosecution not to be based, at least in part, on the testimony of a cooperating co-defendant or co-conspirator.

No one really likes cooperating witnesses. They are loathed by everyone in the criminal justice system, often ostracized by their community, and they almost always shunned by their former associates and friends. If they are sent to prison, other inmates either avoid them or hurt them.

Even prosecutors distance themselves from their cooperators. After all, before they became trusted government witnesses, these people were criminals themselves. And it's common for the people who end up cooperating to start out by lying to investigators.

A cooperator will often go through several different stories before finding something close to the what the government calls "the truth" ("the truth" being defined here as what the government believes happened).

But snitching in criminal cases, especially in federal court, has become so ingrained that the entire system would soon collapse if it disappeared. Cooperating, by whatever name you call it (for Trump, "flipping"), works because it helps secure convictions in otherwise tough cases.

In many criminal cases, the only witness with knowledge of how the crime was planned and committed will be someone who actively participated in it. Although defense lawyers like me may not like it, cooperating witnesses can help the prosecution by providing firsthand knowledge of illegal conduct or by connecting the dots in a complicated case.

Understandably, people charged with a crime are usually not going to incriminate themselves and their associates (which often include family members and close friends) unless they can get something significant in return. And the one thing that the government can give to someone like this is a break on their eventual sentence.

Perhaps, unlike Michael Cohen, people don't strike a deal with the government out of "patriotism and love of country." It's because they can reduce jail time.

And I'm not talking about a day or two. I've represented people who cut their sentence in half, and sometimes completely avoided prison, by cooperating with the government.

Because of this potential benefit, lawyers representing people charged in federal court must discuss the risks and benefits of cooperating with the government. Personally, I don't like it. But I would not be doing my job if I didn't bring it up. The conviction rate in federal court is ridiculously high, and the benefits of cooperating can be very attractive, especially for the first guy who talks.

Trump is right to suggest that "flipping" can be unfair and susceptible to abuse. I have cross-examined many snitches in federal courtrooms across the country who I am certain were lying. It's hard to blame them, given what they face otherwise.

Every plea agreement in federal court requires the cooperator to be "truthful;" again, the government decides if it is, and also, initially whether a cooperator will get any credit at all. So, it should come as no surprise that cooperators quickly learn that the only way they get time off their sentence is to please the government, and that usually means helping them convict someone else.

If President Trump really wanted to "outlaw" flipping as he has suggested, he could do it today. All he needs to do is to instruct the Justice Department to immediately stop bargaining for the testimony of cooperating co-defendants and co-conspirators.

Of course, if he does that, he needs to understand that the number of people convicted in federal court will dramatically plummet. And the number of acquitted defendants will almost certainly include a few guilty ones in the mix.

I'm sure most criminal defense lawyers will join me in thanking President Trump for his comments today. He has made our jobs a lot easier. But he shouldn't be surprised if the career federal prosecutors who represent the United States in courtrooms across the country feel very differently.

Mississippi Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 13731

Reported Deaths: 652
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hinds89824
Lauderdale68056
Madison65321
Scott59210
Neshoba51431
Jones49215
Forrest48635
DeSoto4746
Leake38810
Holmes36923
Rankin3566
Jackson29613
Copiah2844
Attala27314
Monroe24624
Lincoln24520
Leflore24126
Harrison2376
Newton2273
Lamar2205
Yazoo2192
Pearl River20527
Pike20011
Adams18815
Noxubee1656
Lowndes1647
Warren1547
Washington1535
Jasper1453
Bolivar14111
Oktibbeha13910
Covington1311
Clarke13116
Smith13110
Kemper12710
Chickasaw12712
Wayne1250
Lafayette1243
Carroll11310
Marion1108
Lee1085
Coahoma1063
Clay993
Winston981
Lawrence941
Hancock8811
Itawamba857
Simpson850
Wilkinson849
Yalobusha845
Montgomery801
Sunflower793
Grenada752
Union725
Marshall713
Jefferson Davis712
Tippah7011
Panola622
Calhoun604
Tate591
Claiborne582
Humphreys537
Amite521
Walthall490
Perry492
Tunica483
Jefferson400
Prentiss393
Choctaw322
Stone300
Webster281
Pontotoc263
Franklin252
Tishomingo250
Quitman240
Tallahatchie241
George201
Benton150
Alcorn141
Greene71
Sharkey70
Unassigned00

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 15650

Reported Deaths: 580
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Mobile2033111
Jefferson163091
Montgomery127433
Marshall6509
Tuscaloosa55812
Lee51032
Franklin4676
Shelby44719
Tallapoosa40063
Butler35912
Chambers33724
Madison3024
Baldwin2749
Elmore2707
Walker2391
Etowah23811
DeKalb2263
Dallas2063
Coffee2061
Lowndes19310
Sumter1936
Morgan1761
Houston1724
Autauga1683
Calhoun1463
Pike1450
Choctaw1444
Colbert1422
Marengo1416
Russell1370
Lauderdale1352
Bullock1333
Hale1324
Randolph1247
Wilcox1187
Marion11410
Barbour1131
Clarke1092
St. Clair1041
Pickens934
Greene914
Talladega912
Chilton871
Dale850
Cullman780
Limestone770
Jackson712
Winston670
Covington671
Washington655
Henry642
Macon622
Crenshaw602
Bibb591
Blount491
Lawrence430
Escambia433
Perry350
Geneva350
Coosa341
Monroe332
Cherokee332
Conecuh281
Clay272
Lamar200
Cleburne131
Fayette110
Unassigned00
Tupelo
Overcast
72° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 68°
Feels Like: 72°
Columbus
Overcast
71° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 71°
Oxford
Broken Clouds
70° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 70°
Starkville
Overcast
68° wxIcon
Hi: 71° Lo: 64°
Feels Like: 68°
WTVA Radar
WTVA Temperatures
WTVA Severe Weather