Jury set to begin deliberations in Paul Manafort trial

Jurors are set to begin deliberating Thursday morning whether to convict President Donald Trump's former cam...

Posted: Aug 16, 2018 9:57 AM
Updated: Aug 16, 2018 9:57 AM

Jurors are set to begin deliberating Thursday morning whether to convict President Donald Trump's former campaign manager Paul Manafort of bank fraud and tax evasion.

The high-stakes prosecution of Manafort by special counsel Robert Mueller's team reached its conclusion with Wednesday's closing arguments -- with prosecutors accusing Manafort of "lies" and defense lawyers questioning the credibility of key witnesses.

Continents and regions

Eastern Europe

Europe

Government and public administration

Investigations

Paul Manafort

Political Figures - US

Politics

Russia

Russia meddling investigation

Robert Mueller

2016 Presidential election

Donald Trump

Elections (by type)

Elections and campaigns

Political candidates

US Federal elections

US Presidential elections

Court trials

Greg Andres

Law and legal system

Misc people

Trial and procedure

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Criminal law

Rick Gates

Court witnesses

"Mr. Manafort lied to keep more money when he had it, and he lied to get more money when he didn't," said prosecutor Greg Andres. "This is a case about lies."

The jury is scheduled to begin deliberations at 9:30 a.m. ET on Thursday. Judge T.S. Ellis instructed jurors Wednesday evening not to communicate with anyone about the trial.

"Nothing about a cellphone or an iPhone -- goodness, this is now outdated -- a BlackBerry," Ellis said.

The case played out while Trump and the political world watched. Personal revelations about Manafort -- such as his ownership of a $15,000 ostrich jacket -- provided sparks over the course of the 12-day trial.

As the trial reached its end -- with Manafort's defense team deciding not to call any witnesses and arguing that prosecutors hadn't met their burden of proof -- Trump and his lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, watched, continuing to question the credibility of the special counsel's investigation from afar.

RELATED: Giuliani claims Mueller waiting for Manafort verdict to negotiate Trump interview

A win for Mueller's team would send shock waves through Trump's orbit of aides, friends and outside advisers and would heighten anticipation for Mueller's next moves. A loss would increase the chorus of calls for Mueller's investigation to end.

Manafort's defense attorneys suggested Wednesday that the entire prosecution was politically motivated.

Defense attorney Richard Westling said Manafort became the special counsel's victim in a "selective process of pulling" his financial records to concoct a narrative of an "elaborate fraud scheme."

It was "not until the special counsel showed up and started asking questions" that anyone seemed concerned about Manafort's dealings with banks, Westling said, noting that none of the banks involved reported the alleged frauds to the authorities.

He said the special counsel's goal was to "stack up the counts" against Manafort.

Ellis, the judge, instructed the jury not to consider the Manafort team's characterizations of Mueller's team's motives.

'This is a case about lies'

In his closing, Andres argued that Manafort had lied -- repeating the word to the jury several times. He said Manafort had hid his income from Ukraine, lied to federal authorities and defrauded banks.

Manafort's emails, memos and financial records were "littered with lies," Andres said.

He alleged that Manafort's tax returns from 2010 through 2014 are false, and told jurors they must find that Manafort willfully and knowingly lied on the official IRS forms about his income and foreign accounts.

The prosecutor punctuated this by showing the first of several emails the jury would revisit Wednesday -- in which Manafort called one of the 31 foreign accounts "my account." Manafort wrote it "when no one was looking. He did not know one day he would be sitting in this very courtroom," Andres said.

'I'm not asking you to like him'

The testimony of Rick Gates, Manafort's former deputy, took center stage on both sides Wednesday.

Gates has pleaded guilty to crimes in federal court in Washington and is cooperating with Mueller's team. He admitted last week in court to having embezzled money from Manafort and having an extramarital affair a decade ago.

Andres told jurors that before they even consider the potentially fraught testimony of Gates, they should look to 10 other witnesses' testimony and evidence to find Manafort guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

"The star witness in this case is the documents," Andres said.

"Mr. Manafort is a mentor to Mr. Gates, particularly to his own criminal activity," Andres said. He added that Manafort "didn't choose a Boy Scout" to be his partner in crime.

And what about Gates' admitted affair? "Was it to distract you? Does it matter?" Andres asked the jury.

He pointed out that Manafort's lawyers never asked Gates about the alleged bank fraud.

"I'm not asking you to like him," Andres said.

Defense attorney Kevin Downing said Gates "fell apart and showed himself the liar that he is" on the witness stand.

"To the very end, he lied to you," Downing said.

Defense argues Manafort was targeted in 'selective process'

All eyes had been on the defense after it rested without calling any witnesses, with Downing saying Tuesday as he was leaving the courthouse that the defense rested its case because "the government has not met its burden of proof."

Westling referenced Manafort's work on Trump's presidential campaign minutes into his closing, calling Manafort a seasoned political consultant who had earned "great respect" for his work.

Westling also implored the jurors to consider the high burden of proof the government must meet to prove that Manafort is guilty "beyond a reasonable doubt."

"Hold the government to its burden, ladies and gentleman," Westling urged the jurors.

Westling conceded that the evidence against Manafort includes emails. But, he contended, "the problem of email evidence is very much the challenge of what does it look like later."

Mississippi Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 154411

Reported Deaths: 3836
CountyCasesDeaths
DeSoto10332104
Hinds10190199
Harrison7244111
Jackson6521124
Rankin5805103
Lee523695
Madison4964107
Forrest388286
Jones367788
Lauderdale3575147
Lafayette334952
Washington3241108
Lamar296650
Oktibbeha251362
Lowndes243864
Bolivar242984
Panola229653
Neshoba2241118
Marshall221250
Leflore207791
Monroe203978
Pontotoc202929
Lincoln194865
Sunflower192555
Warren178757
Tate177051
Union171026
Copiah167040
Pike164758
Yazoo158840
Scott157930
Itawamba156135
Alcorn154828
Pearl River154168
Coahoma151943
Simpson151953
Prentiss149531
Adams144451
Grenada142845
Leake139444
Holmes132361
Tippah128030
Covington127939
George126425
Winston124526
Hancock123640
Wayne120623
Marion118646
Attala117534
Tishomingo110842
Chickasaw109032
Newton108029
Tallahatchie97727
Clay93427
Clarke93053
Jasper84822
Stone80015
Calhoun78113
Walthall77229
Montgomery75825
Carroll74015
Lawrence73414
Smith72816
Noxubee72517
Yalobusha72328
Perry68126
Tunica62319
Greene61222
Claiborne58916
Jefferson Davis58817
Amite55814
Humphreys54719
Benton49918
Quitman4977
Webster46414
Kemper44718
Wilkinson40422
Jefferson36411
Franklin3535
Choctaw3507
Sharkey32317
Issaquena1204
Unassigned00

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 249524

Reported Deaths: 3578
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson33064500
Mobile19951362
Madison13596148
Tuscaloosa13246154
Montgomery12435236
Shelby1061677
Baldwin889098
Lee781466
Morgan686150
Etowah643966
Calhoun6430121
Marshall635355
Houston537738
DeKalb492236
Cullman451542
Limestone433345
St. Clair432555
Lauderdale422354
Elmore412964
Walker3710111
Talladega359354
Jackson329823
Colbert329642
Blount299740
Autauga278042
Franklin256434
Coffee248315
Dale236254
Chilton227438
Dallas226832
Russell22383
Covington220434
Escambia198931
Tallapoosa184391
Chambers177950
Pike159914
Clarke159819
Marion143636
Winston135123
Lawrence131636
Pickens125718
Geneva12438
Marengo123124
Bibb119617
Barbour117811
Butler117842
Randolph104921
Cherokee103424
Hale97831
Fayette92516
Washington92219
Clay92024
Henry8756
Lowndes80229
Monroe79011
Cleburne77814
Macon74522
Crenshaw72030
Bullock70219
Perry6906
Lamar6898
Conecuh68814
Wilcox64218
Sumter58622
Greene42818
Choctaw42713
Coosa3544
Out of AL00
Unassigned00
Tupelo
Clear
31° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 25°
Feels Like: 31°
Columbus
Clear
30° wxIcon
Hi: 49° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 30°
Oxford
Clear
25° wxIcon
Hi: 49° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 25°
Starkville
Clear
28° wxIcon
Hi: 52° Lo: 21°
Feels Like: 28°
WTVA Radar
WTVA Temperatures
WTVA Severe Weather