HOA will not pay $20 million to victim of collapsed swing set

A homeowners' association in northwest Las Vegas, ordered to pay $20 million because of its failure to perform routin...

Posted: Apr 11, 2018 6:28 PM
Updated: Apr 11, 2018 6:28 PM

A homeowners' association in northwest Las Vegas, ordered to pay $20 million because of its failure to perform routine inspections and maintenance on playground equipment, is now promising homeowners they will not have to foot the bill.

Carl Thompson, who was 15 years old at the time, suffered severe brain injuries from a swing set that collapsed on his head at Lamplight Village in Centennial Hills. The swing set collapsed in 2013. Since then, the Lamplight Village playground has had empty poles where the swings used to sit.

"He was playing basketball," attorney Al Lasso said. "He sat down on the swing set to send a text message. When he sat down, the 42-pound steel bar fell from a height of eight feet and crushed his skull."

"He's trying to finish high school," attorney Sean Claggett said. "This injury caused him to not finish yet, so he's still trying to finish high school."

Lamplight Village's insurance company only covers a maximum of $2 million out of the $20 million awarded at trial.

Since the verdict, homeowners have been scared they could lose their homes. Some said they had no idea this case existed and were considering filing a lawsuit against the HOA for failing to tell them about pending litigation.

"We didn't know anything was going on until we saw a FOX5 tweet about the whole situation, which is quite honestly a very disappointing way to find out news that's going on in your own neighborhood," homeowner Jeremy Long said. "We just moved in. Are we going to lose our house? We have no idea."

At trial, Claggett and Lasso told the jury Lamplight Village had the option to pay a $150 monthly maintenance fee, but declined. The HOA also declined multiple settlement offers.

Michael McKelleb, an attorney who was recently hired to represent Lamplight Village, said all of the settlement offers were for less than the $2 million policy limit. He said Lamplight Village wanted to settle, but couldn't.

"The (HOA) board didn't have authority," McKelleb explained. "The policy provided that authority to the insurance carrier... The insurance company turned that down and went to trial."

"An insurance carrier should not be stingy with paying policy limits," he continued. "In hindsight, it was far too great of a risk."

Lamplight Village is now filing a claim against its insurance company, QBE Insurance, for rolling the dice with someone else's money in a case they could not win. First, the victim has to take a risk by signing a settlement with the HOA.

"If (the insurance company) were to win the case, then the settlement would still provide that Mr. Thompson has agreed not to go after the homeowners," McKelleb said. "(Thompson) is not looking to make more victims. He doesn't want to get paid from the homeowners by taking their homes from them. That doesn't really help anybody, and quite honestly to get the kind of money he would need from them, it's not going to be there... I don't think anybody would be interested in displacing 284 families."

Lasso and Claggett have not yet commented on the settlement. McKelleb, who did not yet represent Lamplight Village at the time of trial, said the settlement had already been signed.

McKelleb said he feels horrible for the victim and hopes he can help ensure Thompson is paid the money he's owed from the insurance company.

"I don't know what would have happened if (my client) had had a maintenance program," McKelleb said. "This play set should have lasted for 20 years if a 300 pound person had been swinging on it. If you're a board member who doesn't know anything about swing sets, and that's your understanding, and it's a fairly new play set, it doesn't seem unreasonable to think, 'Well, maybe in the future we'll get a program to have it looked at every now and then.'"

McKelleb also said all homeowners were notified about the pending litigation through a letter and as a part of their CC&R documents.

If Lamplight Village wins its case against QBE Insurance, Thompson could theoretically earn more than $20 million and homeowners would not have to pay a dime, McKelleb said. If Lamplight Village loses, homeowners may have to pay for attorney fees, which would be considerably less than $20 million.

Representatives for QBE Insurance have not yet replied to FOX5's requests for comment. Stay with FOX5 News for continuing updates on this case.

Mississippi Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 148387

Reported Deaths: 3769
CountyCasesDeaths
DeSoto9874101
Hinds9821198
Harrison6982110
Jackson6218119
Rankin5417102
Lee498495
Madison4711106
Forrest375086
Jones352488
Lauderdale3412145
Lafayette319749
Washington3153107
Lamar286349
Oktibbeha243562
Bolivar240884
Lowndes232864
Neshoba2189118
Panola218849
Marshall211950
Leflore203490
Pontotoc199128
Monroe196077
Sunflower191055
Lincoln187865
Warren174157
Tate166951
Union165325
Pike160958
Copiah160440
Yazoo152939
Scott151829
Itawamba151134
Coahoma149543
Pearl River149467
Alcorn148228
Simpson146353
Prentiss143730
Adams139250
Grenada138845
Leake133243
Holmes127861
Tippah123730
George123524
Covington120938
Winston120024
Hancock117639
Wayne116923
Marion114846
Attala111234
Tishomingo108742
Chickasaw106932
Newton104229
Tallahatchie96727
Clay89927
Clarke89153
Jasper81722
Walthall76028
Stone75214
Calhoun73713
Montgomery72825
Carroll71415
Lawrence70714
Yalobusha70527
Smith70316
Noxubee70017
Perry65826
Tunica60219
Greene59722
Claiborne57916
Jefferson Davis56017
Humphreys53119
Amite52714
Benton49017
Quitman4846
Webster42314
Kemper42118
Wilkinson38722
Jefferson34711
Franklin3345
Choctaw3157
Sharkey30817
Issaquena1144
Unassigned00

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 241957

Reported Deaths: 3572
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson31809500
Mobile19651361
Madison12964148
Tuscaloosa12946154
Montgomery12263236
Shelby1016177
Baldwin857698
Lee771866
Morgan648050
Calhoun6215119
Etowah618266
Marshall618255
Houston522438
DeKalb480436
Cullman433442
Limestone418645
St. Clair413655
Elmore403764
Lauderdale396754
Walker3620111
Talladega347954
Jackson311723
Colbert306042
Blount287940
Autauga270442
Franklin250233
Coffee242015
Dale231754
Dallas225232
Russell22123
Chilton220638
Covington218034
Escambia197931
Chambers176450
Tallapoosa175491
Pike158114
Clarke157619
Marion137136
Winston131123
Lawrence126336
Pickens121618
Geneva12108
Marengo120224
Barbour117010
Bibb117017
Butler115341
Randolph101921
Cherokee101024
Hale96031
Clay91024
Washington90719
Fayette89316
Henry8526
Lowndes79429
Monroe78311
Cleburne76914
Macon73022
Crenshaw70930
Bullock69419
Conecuh68314
Perry6836
Lamar6678
Wilcox63118
Sumter57522
Greene42318
Choctaw42113
Coosa3414
Out of AL00
Unassigned00
Tupelo
Overcast
57° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 57°
Columbus
Overcast
58° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 48°
Feels Like: 58°
Oxford
Overcast
55° wxIcon
Hi: 60° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 55°
Starkville
Broken Clouds
55° wxIcon
Hi: 58° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 55°
WTVA Radar
WTVA Temperatures
WTVA Severe Weather