Supreme Court takes on privacy rights of unauthorized rental car drivers

When Terrence Byrd was stopped by police in 2014 for a minor traffic infraction, he couldn't have expected that his c...

Posted: Jan 10, 2018 7:19 AM
Updated: Jan 10, 2018 7:19 AM

When Terrence Byrd was stopped by police in 2014 for a minor traffic infraction, he couldn't have expected that his case would eventually come before the Supreme Court.

In the heat of the moment, he had to deal with the fact that he was the unauthorized driver of a rental car.

The case centers on a drug conviction that followed from the search of a rental car

The government claimed it did not need the driver's consent to search the car, since his name was not on the rental agreement

And that there were 49 bricks of heroin in his trunk.

After his arrest, however, Byrd's lawyer would seek to suppress the evidence against him, citing the Fourth Amendment's guarantee against unreasonable search and seizure.

The government claimed it did not need his consent to search the car because Byrd had no reasonable expectation of privacy due to the fact that his name was not listed on the rental agreement.

Byrd was subsequently convicted of drug charges and sentenced to 120 months in prison.

Four years later, Byrd's appeal has made it to the highest court in the land and the justices will determine whether Byrd had diminished privacy rights under the Fourth Amendment.

Privacy experts are watching to see whether the justices will broaden the government's power to search under the Fourth Amendment. Some fear that a ruling against Byrd might disproportionally affect lower-income Americans, who are more likely to depend upon rental cars for everyday travel because they can't afford their own vehicles.

In court Tuesday, Justice Sonia Sotomayor was concerned about the impact a ruling against Byrd would have on police power. She noted that even though Byrd's name was not on the rental agreement, his friend, who had rented the car, allowed him to drive it.

"If we rule that someone without permission has no expectation of privacy even when the renter has given it to them, then what we're authorizing is the police to stop every rental car and search every rental car, without probable cause," she said.

Justice Stephen Breyer worried about the impact of the court's opinion on other contract-related cases concerning, for instance, "houses, apartments, sublets, summer cabins," all of which are governed by "understandings" and "leases."

Thinking out loud, Breyer tested several different rules hoping to find something that would be easy for police officers to understand. "Fourth Amendment law is too complicated in a sense already," he concluded.

Justice Elena Kagan noted that the contract violation -- someone driving a rental car even though his name wasn't on the list -- is not that rare.

"Let's be frank," she said, it's "not uncommon."

"What eliminates the right of privacy that you would normally get by opening up the car of a door and sitting in the front seat and turning the ignition key?" she asked.

On the other hand, Chief Justice John Roberts looked at the case from the perspective of the police officers making the stops and being forced to determine whether the driver had permission from the renter to drive the car.

"Are (police) supposed to conduct an inquisition?" he asked.

The case dates back to 2014, when a police officer in Pennsylvania became suspicious because Byrd was sitting so far back in the driver's seat he was barely visible. The officer noted that the Ford Fusion was a rental car and began to follow it on a four-lane highway. When Byrd failed to properly move into the right lane after passing a slower truck, the officer pulled him over for the minor violation, according to police.

After some questioning, Byrd admitted that he had a marijuana cigarette in the car, according to police. The officers informed him that because his name was not on the rental agreement they could search the car without his consent. Later, police said they found the heroin. Among the charges was one count of possession of heroin with the intent to distribute.

A three-judge panel of the 3rd US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Byrd, citing its own precedent "that society generally does not share or recognize an expectation of privacy for those who have gained possession and control over a rental vehicle they have borrowed without the permission of the rental company."

In briefs to the Supreme Court, a lawyer for Byrd emphasized that his client's girlfriend had allowed him to drive the car that she had rented.

"She has given him both possession and control of the car, and he reasonably believes that he can exclude strangers and the government from intruding upon his private personal family possessions stored in the car," Robert M. Loeb wrote. Loeb stressed that Byrd's constitutional protections should not materially change because it turned out that he was not the authorized driver under a rental agreement.

Lawyers for the government, however, argued in court papers that he "did not own the car, had not rented it, and was not allowed to drive it."

"He cannot assert Fourth Amendment rights to object to its search," Solicitor General Noel Francisco said.

The American Civil Liberties Union filed a brief in support of Byrd arguing that the lower court opinion would "severely curtail the scope of the Fourth Amendment" and affect a "broad swath of the population, especially individuals who have come to depend on rental cars for everyday travel because they cannot afford to purchase their own vehicle."

Mississippi Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 115763

Reported Deaths: 3263
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hinds7973177
DeSoto703979
Harrison522384
Jackson457884
Rankin394086
Madison383194
Lee357380
Forrest304678
Jones292484
Washington258399
Lafayette250443
Lauderdale2478135
Lamar225538
Oktibbeha202454
Bolivar201677
Neshoba1849111
Lowndes179962
Panola170040
Leflore167187
Sunflower162349
Warren154855
Monroe150673
Pontotoc147220
Marshall143129
Lincoln140157
Pike138456
Copiah137536
Scott125429
Coahoma124937
Grenada122638
Yazoo122234
Simpson121549
Union118825
Tate116839
Leake115041
Holmes114760
Itawamba113925
Pearl River113660
Adams108544
Prentiss106120
Wayne101722
Alcorn100112
George99218
Covington97527
Marion95042
Tippah90322
Newton86627
Chickasaw85526
Tallahatchie84526
Winston84121
Hancock84028
Tishomingo81241
Attala79426
Clarke75851
Clay69321
Jasper68717
Walthall63927
Calhoun62612
Noxubee59817
Smith59416
Montgomery54923
Yalobusha54514
Claiborne53716
Tunica53517
Lawrence51814
Perry49423
Carroll49312
Greene47818
Stone47514
Humphreys43816
Amite42513
Quitman4206
Jefferson Davis41011
Webster37613
Benton3416
Wilkinson33820
Kemper32615
Sharkey28514
Jefferson27610
Franklin2423
Choctaw2086
Issaquena1074
Unassigned00

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 158701

Reported Deaths: 2680
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson23292377
Mobile16916315
Tuscaloosa10345140
Montgomery10250197
Madison935096
Shelby739063
Baldwin665869
Lee654665
Calhoun459961
Marshall439550
Etowah428551
Houston417034
Morgan416435
DeKalb342629
Elmore320853
St. Clair295542
Limestone287230
Walker279492
Talladega266435
Cullman248024
Lauderdale229442
Jackson215915
Autauga205931
Franklin205531
Colbert202132
Russell19493
Blount193225
Chilton188432
Dallas186627
Coffee177111
Dale176351
Covington174729
Escambia172730
Clarke135217
Chambers135044
Pike134113
Tallapoosa132987
Marion108129
Barbour10339
Marengo101922
Butler101140
Winston92913
Geneva9067
Lawrence85832
Pickens85218
Bibb84014
Randolph82716
Hale76830
Washington74912
Clay74412
Cherokee73814
Henry7176
Lowndes71328
Bullock64917
Monroe64610
Crenshaw60830
Perry5926
Fayette57713
Cleburne5698
Wilcox56812
Conecuh56113
Macon53620
Lamar4965
Sumter47221
Choctaw39212
Greene34216
Coosa2043
Out of AL00
Unassigned00
Tupelo
Overcast
59° wxIcon
Hi: 68° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 59°
Columbus
Broken Clouds
59° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 59°
Oxford
Overcast
54° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 54°
Starkville
Broken Clouds
55° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 55°
WTVA Radar
WTVA Temperatures
WTVA Severe Weather